Sanibel Rentals

Glass Casa lists 123 Sanibel vacation rentals here, each with live prices for your dates, bookable direct with no added 3rd party fees.

Destinations
Bedrooms
Guests
Property Type
Must Haves
20 of 123 rentals
Grid ListClear filters
Loggerhead Cay 361

Loggerhead Cay 361

SanibelCondominium

Spacious Ground-Floor Courtyard-View Condo with a King Bedroom, Sleeps 6

22.06
Pointe Santo C26

Pointe Santo C26

SanibelCondominium

Sanibel 2BR Condo with Beach Views, Private Balcony and Communal Pool

22.06
Sanibel Vista

Sanibel Vista

SanibelHouse

Pet-Friendly 4-Bedroom Sanibel Island Retreat for 8, Steps from Shelling and Bike Trails

43.58 Pet Friendly
Sand Pointe 116

Sand Pointe 116

SanibelCondominium

Fully Remodeled 2BR/2BA Condo with Panoramic Gulf-Front Views on Sanibel

22.06★ 5.0 (12)
Loggerhead Cay 321

Loggerhead Cay 321

SanibelCondominium

Ground-Floor Garden-View Condo Steps from the Pool and a Short Walk to the Beach

22.06
Loggerhead Cay 343

Loggerhead Cay 343

SanibelCondominium

Courtyard-View 2-Bedroom Loggerhead Cay Condo near the Sanibel Beach

22.06
Donax Village 15

Donax Village 15

SanibelCondominium

Brand-New 2-Bedroom Loft Condo with Balcony and Communal Pool on Sanibel Island

22.06
Pointe Santo E23

Pointe Santo E23

SanibelCondominium

Beachfront Sanibel Condo With Gulf Views From the Balcony, Sleeps 5

22.05★ 5.0 (4)
Seagrape Village 2

Seagrape Village 2

SanibelCondominium

Beachfront 3-Bedroom Sanibel Condo with Balcony Gulf Views and Communal Pool

33.08★ 5.0 (3)
Pointe Santo C41

Pointe Santo C41

SanibelCondominium

Beach-View 2 Bedroom Condo at Pointe Santo with Balcony and Communal Pool by the Gulf

22.06
Seagrape Village 4

Seagrape Village 4

SanibelCondominium

Beachfront 3-Bedroom Retreat with Balcony, Beach Views and Pool on Sanibel

33.08
Pointe Santo C35

Pointe Santo C35

SanibelCondominium

Beach-View 3-Bedroom Condo at Pointe Santo on Sanibel, Sleeps 8 with Pool Access

32.08★ 5.0 (2)
Loggerhead Cay 234

Loggerhead Cay 234

SanibelCondominium

Beach-View 2-Bedroom Condo on Sanibel Island with Balcony and Pets Welcome

22.06 Pet Friendly
Sand Pointe 122

Sand Pointe 122

SanibelCondominium

Beachfront 2-Bedroom with Fantastic Gulf Views, Completely Remodeled Summer 2026

22.06
A Sun Burst

A Sun Burst

SanibelHouse

Easygoing 3-Bedroom Sanibel Island Home for 10, with a Balcony and Shaded Deck

32.010
Gramma Dot's Marina House

Gramma Dot's Marina House

SanibelHouse

Waterfront 3-Bedroom Retreat at Sanibel Marina with Balcony and Deck, Sleeps 6

32.06★ 5.0 (1)
Kittiwake

Kittiwake

SanibelHouse

Easygoing 3-Bedroom Sanibel Island Home for Eight, With Balcony and Shaded Deck Space

32.08
Mariner Pointe 1083

Mariner Pointe 1083

SanibelCondominium

Bay Front Views and Communal Pool in a 2-Bed, 2-Bath Sanibel Condo for Six

22.06
Coquina Beach 5H

Coquina Beach 5H

SanibelCondominium

Remodeled 2-Bedroom Sanibel Condo with Loft, Patio and Community Pool

22.06★ 5.0 (2)
Blue Heron Home

Blue Heron Home

SanibelHouse

Pet-Friendly Pool Home on the Sanibel River with a Screened Heated Pool, Sleeps 6

33.06 Pet Friendly
F.A.V.R.Better Business BureauVacation Rentals Managers AssociationSanCap ChamberSCVRMABooking.comVRBOHomeawayTripAdvisorGenerali Travel InsuranceAirbnb